There has never been another band quite like Jethro Tull. Formed in 1967 and built around Ian Anderson — singer, songwriter and the unlikeliest of rock flautists — they roamed from blues to folk to full-blown progressive rock and hard rock, rarely staying in one place for two albums running. Along the way they made one of prog’s defining statements and a run of beloved folk-rock classics. Here is our fellow fan’s ranking of a core selection from their long and restless career.

The short version

For the heart of Tull, start with Aqualung, Thick as a Brick, Stand Up, Songs from the Wood and Minstrel in the Gallery. Between them they cover the band’s most famous album, its boldest progressive experiment and the peak of its folk-rock years. The full ranking is below.

A band that won’t sit still

Part of what makes Tull so rewarding is also what makes them hard to label. They began as a blues band, became eclectic folk-rockers, made two of prog’s most audacious album-length pieces, then settled into a rich English folk-rock sound before toughening up again in the 1980s. Ian Anderson has long been wary of the “prog” tag — yet Thick as a Brick, a single forty-three-minute song spread across two sides, is one of the genre’s landmark works. A note, too: Tull’s catalogue runs to more than twenty studio albums, and the fourteen ranked here are a core selection drawn mainly from their prime era.

How we ranked them

This is one fan’s order, weighing ambition, songwriting and how each record has aged across the band’s many styles. The facts are accurate; the ranking is a starting point — and with a band this varied, your own favourites may land in a very different order.

The essential five

At the top sits Aqualung (1971), the band’s most famous and most enduring album, home to the title track, “Locomotive Breath” and “Cross-Eyed Mary”. Thick as a Brick (1972) is the audacious masterpiece, a single side-long-times-two epic that topped the US charts; Stand Up (1969) is the breakthrough where the band first found its eclectic voice, complete with a jazz-folk reworking of Bach’s “Bourée”. Songs from the Wood (1977) is the joyous high point of their folk-rock years, and Minstrel in the Gallery (1975) balances acoustic delicacy and electric muscle as well as anything they did.

Charmed by the flute? The books go deeper →

Reliably great

The next tier is full of riches. Heavy Horses (1978) is the warm, pastoral heart of the folk trilogy; Benefit (1970) is the darker, underrated album that bridged the blues and prog eras. A Passion Play (1973), the second of the album-length pieces, was savaged on release and has since been reappraised as a fascinating, demanding work. Stormwatch (1979) closes the folk-rock run on a stormy, atmospheric note, and The Broadsword and the Beast (1982) marries that folk sensibility to a bigger 1980s sound to fine effect.

The interesting middle

Here the catalogue is more uneven. War Child (1974) has strong songs but a slightly scattered feel after the grand statements that preceded it; and Crest of a Knave (1987) is the polished, Dire-Straits-flavoured comeback that famously — and controversially — won the band a Grammy.

For completists

Two albums tend to sit at the bottom. The debut This Was (1968) is an enjoyable blues-rock record but the least characteristic of the band, made before guitarist Martin Barre joined and before they truly became themselves. And Too Old to Rock ’n’ Roll: Too Young to Die! (1976) is the awkward concept album that most fans rank as the weakest of the 1970s. Both have their moments, but neither is the place to begin.

The core selection, in order

A core selection from the prime era, in chronological order — Tull’s full catalogue runs further still. Click any record for the full write-up.

Where to start

Begin with Aqualung — it is the most immediate way into the band and the one most likely to hook you. Follow it with Thick as a Brick for their boldest prog statement, Stand Up for the early eclectic spark, and Songs from the Wood if you fall for their folk side.

The players

Jethro Tull have always revolved around Ian Anderson, whose flute, voice and wry songwriting are the band’s unmistakable signature — the image of him playing flute balanced on one leg is as iconic as anything in 1970s rock. From Stand Up onward, guitarist Martin Barre was his long-serving foil and the band’s second pillar, while a rotating cast of gifted keyboardists, bassists and drummers filled out the line-up across the decades. In a famous twist, the band won the very first Grammy for Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance in 1989 — beating Metallica, to widespread astonishment, with a record that is anything but metal.

Why they still matter

Jethro Tull made the unlikeliest of instruments — the flute — central to a rock band, and built a catalogue that few could match for sheer variety, moving between progressive rock, English folk and hard rock without ever losing their identity. Their best albums remain singular and richly rewarding, the work of a band that followed its own path for decades and answered to no genre but its own.

Go deeper

Keep exploring: read about the best Jethro Tull songs, see every Jethro Tull album in order, find your way in with our where-to-start-with-Tull guide, or dig up the most underrated Jethro Tull albums. You can also place them in the bigger picture with our list of the best progressive rock albums of all time.

Find your next read on the bookshelf below →