Before the breakthrough. The Difference Machine is Big Big Train’s atmospheric 2007 album: a darker, more experimental record that set the stage for the beloved English band’s golden era.

The short version

The 2007 album by English progressive rock band Big Big Train, and their fifth studio release, on their own English Electric label. A richer, more atmospheric and experimental record than its predecessors, it is a reflective concept album woven around ideas of chance, communication and connection across vast distances, its cosmic imagery threaded through melancholy, mellotron-soaked prog. Harder-edged and more challenging than the band’s later, more pastoral work, it stands as a fascinating turning point — the last album before the line-up that would define their classic era.

A turning point

By 2007, Big Big Train had been plotting their own course on the English prog scene for over a decade, anchored throughout by co-founders Greg Spawton and Andy Poole. The Difference Machine, their fifth album, found the band in a more ambitious, experimental mood, with Sean Filkins on lead vocals and Steve Hughes on drums, joined by a cast of notable guests — including Marillion’s Pete Trewavas and Spock’s Beard’s Nick D’Virgilio and Dave Meros. D’Virgilio, in particular, would soon become central to the band. It was the last album of an era: soon after, the line-up would change and Big Big Train’s golden run would begin.

The sound

The Difference Machine is atmospheric, melancholic English prog, darker and more experimental than the warm, pastoral sound the band would later become known for. Overdriven guitars, plentiful mellotron — strings, flute and choir — sax and synth solos build a rich, moody soundscape, drawing on classic prog like Genesis, Van der Graaf Generator and King Crimson alongside the atmosphere of modern alternative rock. A recurring viola theme threads through the album, tying its long, ambitious tracks together. Challenging and a grower, it rewards patient, repeated listening with real depth and emotion.

Reading up on modern prog? The books go deeper →

The songs

The album opens with the gentle instrumental ‘Hope This Finds You,’ whose viola melody becomes the record’s recurring motif. ‘Perfect Cosmic Storm’ is its most ambitious track, its sweeping cosmic imagery and powerful melodies pointing the way toward the band’s later epics. The fourteen-minute ‘Pick Up If You’re There’ is the standout for many, a sprawling mini-epic full of mean guitar, great saxophone and dramatic twists. Together they show a band reaching for something bigger.

Reception and legacy

The Difference Machine drew favourable reviews in the prog and rock press and marked a clear step up in ambition for Big Big Train, even if it remains more experimental and divisive than their later, more melodic work. It is best understood as a bridge: soon after its release, Sean Filkins and Steve Hughes moved on, and the arrival of new singer David Longdon — alongside a settled line-up with Nick D’Virgilio and others — launched the acclaimed run that made the band’s name. For fans exploring their story, it is a compelling, atmospheric early chapter.

The verdict

The Difference Machine is Big Big Train at their most atmospheric and experimental: a darker, mellotron-rich concept album that set the stage for greater things. Come for the ambitious ‘Perfect Cosmic Storm’ and the sprawling ‘Pick Up If You’re There.’ It leads directly into the band’s golden era — the acclaimed run of albums including Folklore and Grand Tour — and stands as a fascinating look at one of modern English prog’s finest bands on the cusp of greatness. Well worth exploring for the dedicated listener.

Browse the bookshelf in the footer →